IncludeNYC logo

New York City Council Education Committee, Oversight Hearing on Examining School Bus Transportation Services in NYC

Published
November 18, 2026
Type
Testimony

We thank the New York City Council’s Committee on Education for holding yet another oversight hearing on school bus transportation services in New York City and for the opportunity to testify.  INCLUDEnyc is an independent nonprofit that supports young people ages 0-26 with known or suspected disabilities and their families across New York City. For over 43 years, we have helped New York City families navigate the complex special education and support systems.

For many students with disabilities, school transportation is far more than a way to get to and from school. It is fundamental to their legal right to a free appropriate public education. When buses fail to arrive, are chronically late, or cannot safely accommodate a student’s individual needs, children are denied critical instructional time, mandated services, and meaningful opportunities to learn, make educational progress, and participate alongside their peers. These failures not only undermine students’ educational rights but also place significant emotional, financial, and logistical burdens on their families.

Parents report children waiting more than an hour for buses, spending up to three hours traveling to or from school, and arriving at incorrect locations. Some students have assigned routes but no available driver or bus. Others cannot board because their mandated transportation paraprofessional has not been assigned. 

We are particularly concerned about overcrowding and excessively long routes. Families report buses transporting students of vastly different ages, sometimes serving four, five, or even six schools on a single route. These arrangements too often mean students missing instruction and related services in the morning and afternoon. It is also especially harmful for students with medical, developmental, sensory, or behavioral needs. Equally important, it means tens of thousands of students receiving special education services are excluded from their school and class communities daily. This is not okay. 

Staffing shortages and contracting practices compound these problems. Long-distance or multi-borough routes can be difficult to staff, leaving students without dependable transportation. Yet these failures should not be attributed solely to drivers and attendants, many of whom work tirelessly under challenging circumstances. The underlying problems are systemic and demand systemic solutions. They also should proactively be addressed in all near-future RFPs and related citywide contracts. 

Communication with families and schools and accountability are equally troubling. Parents describe unanswered questions, automated responses arriving weeks after complaints, and confusion about whether schools, bus companies, or the Office of Pupil Transportation (OPT) are responsible for resolving problems.

Transportation arrangements also depend on accurate student information being entered, approved, and transmitted across multiple systems. When any step breaks down, families face delays as agencies and staff shift responsibility, leaving them in the dark and feeling invisible. 

Meanwhile, rideshare services and reimbursements have become fallback solutions. While we support this additional mode of transportation as an option when needed, these alternatives often require an adult to accompany the student, forcing parents to miss work, risk their jobs, or shoulder additional financial burdens.

INCLUDEnyc urges the City Council and NYCPS to prioritize the following reforms:

  • Strengthen transparency and accountability: We support Intro. 0835-2026, which would establish a publicly accessible school bus performance dashboard. Families deserve timely, understandable information about missed pickups, excessive delays, and transportation reliability. This transparency is especially critical for students with disabilities whose access to education and mandated services depends on consistent, appropriate transportation.
  • Modernize school bus contracting while protecting workers: We also support New York State legislation A.8440/S.1018 and urge the Council to support enacting it. It would preserve essential employment protections for school bus workers while addressing barriers to competitively rebidding transportation contracts. Together, these measures could help NYCPS establish stronger contractual standards for student safety, transportation reliability, workforce stability, family communication, and accountability. For students with disabilities, meaningful transportation reform must be measured not simply by whether a bus is assigned, but by whether every student can safely, consistently, and promptly access their education.
  • Improve school-level coordination and family communication. NYCPS must mandate comprehensive training for school transportation coordinators, establish clearly identifiable contacts responsible for resolving problems, and ensure families receive timely, accessible updates. This includes requiring individual schools to post the name and contact information of their transportation coordinator on their website. This helps parents know who to contact directly when problems arise.
  • Prioritize students’ individual needs. NYCPS must reduce excessively long, overcrowded routes; ensure timely assignment of transportation paraprofessionals; improve coordination of IEP-mandated accommodations; expand access to transportation for after-school and weekend programs; and update the Chancellor’s Regulations to reflect these responsibilities.

These longstanding problems are antithetical to this administration’s focus on student safety and belonging, academic rigor, true integration, and family and community engagement.  It is 2026, and no child should miss school or have declines in educational progress because the City cannot provide safe, reliable transportation. And no parent should have to risk losing employment simply to get their child to and from school. 

New York City must do better at recognizing that, to make the school transportation system reliable and meet the individualized needs of all students with disabilities who take a school bus to and from school every day, they TOO can participate fully and equitably in their education. 

Thank you for taking the time to consider these important matters. We look forward to partnering with you to improve equity and access for all students with disabilities in New York City. 

Respectfully submitted, 

Lori Podvesker

Director of Disability and Education Policy

INCLUDEnyc